image text special

'Either it is raining or it is not (at a particular space and time)', a Group Show at WallRiss, Fribourg

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

article image

Do I contradict myself ? Very well, then, I contradict myself. (I am large, I contain multitudes.) — Walt Whitman, “Song of Myself”

Vorrei e non vorrei — Zerlina, “Là ci darem la mano”, Don Giovanni

I can’t go on, I’ll go on − Samuel Becket, «The Unnamble»

Either it is raining or it is not states a simple principle known as the principle of non-contradiction : no contradiction is true. Following this principle, it cannot be the case that the proposition «It is raining» is true and the negation of this proposition, «It is not raining», is also true. The conjunction «It is raining and it is not raining» cannot be true, because nothing can be true and false.

If contradictions were true, nothing could be meaningful. Something is indeed meaningful only if it excludes something : a claim that rules out nothing, says nothing. This goes further : if a proposition (like «It is raining») does not rule out the negation of the proposition («It is not raining»), it rules out nothing. The premiss here is the following : a proposition is meaningful if and only if it rules out something. But is this true ? Consider the claim «Everything is true». This rules nothing out : it entails everything. But the claim is meaningful, since we can test it (it is false, not everything is true). Moreover, the negation of the claim, «Something is not true», is meaningful (and true).

However, in a range of ambivalence, contradictions lies at heart of value judgment. Often, speakers affirm contradictions of the form «a (a proposition) is v (a value judgment like «good», «bad», etc.) and a is not v». When affirmed in full awareness, what can be said of the people holding those contradictions ? They believe them and do not believe them, like illustrated by the«Sorry not sorry»or «I’m not sayin’ I’m just sayin’» trending meme on social medias. In marketing strategies, «work not work» has been taken by Samsonite (the luggages), «Guilty not guilty» by Gucci.

Sometimes, in cases close to irony, it is the recognition of the apparent contradiction that the speaker exploits to generate the higher-order coherence of the message : Not punk enough to be punk but not not punk enough to be not punk. Another way to produce an effect is to use contradiction involving prosody (playing on auditory measure such as tone) : He’s still great, but he’s not GREAT.

Either it is raining or it is not (at a particular space and time) is therefore a proposition about certain operations inside a frame. Playing on the dry formalism of contradictions and the way they move throughout a determinate logical system, it uses the shifting and entailments inside an operative framework to act on a certain rationalization of the exhibition. Outside of a usual pathway, the works in WallRiss perform at the intersection between exposure and retreating. They voyage then as a vessel : as a sign of previous arrivals and departures, a threshold between worlds, a contact zone for communities across time. As Sherlock Holmes states in the «Disappearance of Lady Frances Carfax», it is in this kind of in-between that one finds the truth : «Now we will take another line of reasoning. When you follow two separate chains of thought, Watson, you will find some point of intersection which should approximate to the truth.»

 .
23.3.19 — 3.5.19
 .

Loucia Carlier, Christopher Füllemann, Marie Gyger, Inside Job (Ula Lucinska & Michal Knychaus), Philip Ortelli, Axelle Stiefel & Lény Bernay, Paulo Wirz

 .
Photo by Guillaume Baeriswyl
 .

.
preview image

'Verharzungen' by Max Negrelli, Yana Tsegay at The Reference, Frankfurt am Main

preview image

'A Rigged and Sudden Machinery' by Stefan Schwartzman
 at MX Gallery, New York

preview image

'TFW Too Intelligent' by Kid Xanthrax at Galerie U Mloka, Olomouc

preview image

Ieva Putniņa (Kaspars Groševs) – Fat Gnomes (Ears of New Jersey) at Riga Circus E

preview image

'Snowshoe Hare and Allies' by Emily Jones at Almanac, London

preview image

'All the World’s Organ’s' by Mitchell Kehe at 15 Orient, New York

preview image

'So Fresh On Top, So Rotten Below' by Saskia Te Nicklin at Vin Vin, Vienna

preview image

'Sourire aux Anges' by Jean-Baptiste Janisset at Chiffonnier, Dijon

preview image

'Luna Nuova', a Group Show Curated by Edoardo Manzoni and Giada Olivotto at Resid

preview image

'Bodyhunter: Monist Crysis' by Nik Kosmas at Alyssa Davis Gallery, New York

preview image

'Fixed Gear' by Emmy Skensved, Hosted by Superdeals at Château Nour, Brussels

preview image

'Kā skan, Tā atskan', a Group Show at No Moon, New York

preview image

Demise: of a Dream + Smegma at A10, Valencia

preview image

'Love and die' by Tobias Spichtig at CAC-La synagogue de Delme, Delme

preview image

'Floor is Lava', a Group Show at City Surfer Office, Prague

preview image

'Ever After' by Julian-Jakob Kneer at Shore, Vienna

preview image

'VERDANT' by Mirko Canesi at Deborah Bowmann, Brussels

preview image

'how to whisper' by Matei Dumitriu at Bluf, Bucharest

More